In medicine, reckoning with racism includes reappraising the very syntax we use every day. Proud to add my voice w/ @J_Ikeme and @RWGrantMD in this @JAMAInternMed pub addressing:

Does race/ethnicity belong in the first line of the patient

Some background: I’ve struggled with this question since early in medical school

Medical syntax is designed to communicate information in a predictable sequence with key elements prioritized to facilitate efficient communication and formation of an assessment and plan

2/
From preclinical lectures to Qbank questions to clerkship rotations, race/ethnicity was often prioritized in the same sentence as age + gender.

I grew accustomed to reading/hearing: a 70-year-old Black man w/ history of x, a 50-year-old Hispanic woman presented w/ y.

3/
However, when it came time for me to use race/ethnicity, there was always tension. Race/ethnicity are self/socially-ascribed identities that in clinical practice are almost always assumed by providers based on appearance. I was also concerned about the potential for bias

4/
I wondered how my own care would be impacted or not impacted by my ethnicity (Hispanic) – I have light skin so I’m not sure if my doctors would even identify me as such – but how would my care be different if I was presented as a 30-year-old Hispanic male?

5/
That said, I was taught race could have implications for the assessment and plan (e.g., eGFR – I’ll come back to this). Moreover, racial disparities are real and could inform a pt’s care. So, I reported race on a PRN basis, but still felt uneasy. I wondered what others did …

6/
In @JAMAInternMed, we get insight from Balderston et al. on this use of race in medicine. In 1200 admissions to an academic medical center, 33% of Black pts had their race documented in the first line of their admission note compared to 17% of white pts
https://t.co/GMKXsx6Z02
7/
They also found that Black clinicians had 58% lower odds of documenting race than white clinicians and attending physicians had 2.37 times greater odds of documenting race than resident physicians.

8/
Though this study was conducted at a single center and does not investigate *why* Black patients had race identified more often or *how* this impacts subsequent care, the differential documentation of race in the HPI merits further scrutiny.

9/
Fortunately, there has been much scrutiny and expertise dedicated to the (mis)representation of race in medicine this year – including this important work by Amutah et al.

https://t.co/8Ej4LvDi2a

10/
🔑 pts:
-race is not a meaningful scientific construct in the absence of context
-race is not a biologic category based on innate differences that produce unequal health outcomes.
-it is a social category that reflects the impact of unequal social experiences on health

11/
🔑 points (cont.):
-Unfortunately, race in medical education often misses the mark and can lead to race-based diagnostic bias or pathologizing race (see below table)

12/
Notably, they “are not arguing that race is irrelevant” but rather “that it can be a starting point to generate hypotheses about environmental exposures and social processes that produce disparities” and that “discussing race is essential to promoting an antiracist culture.”
13/
In another expert review, Borrell et al. similarly write it is “inappropriate to simply abandon the use of race in research and clinical practice ... these variables capture important epidemiologic information, including social determinants of health”

https://t.co/Yt28mUqPqg
14/
Key points:
- Race, ethnicity, and ancestry have a complex and intertwined relationship that demands nuanced analyses
- we should not assume that environmental, social, or genetic factors represent the only contributors to a given disease until causation has been proven

15/
Back to eGFR, and the use of race in research and clinical decision making, at large. My thoughts continue to evolve as a clinician and researcher on handling race in this context, but I want to provide one last article by Vyas et al:

https://t.co/aVM0k4GCEv

16/
This article provides a useful framework to eval race correction in clinical settings:
Is race correction based on robust evidence?
Is there a plausible causal mechanism for the racial difference?
Would implementing this correction relieve or exacerbate health inequities?

17/
As it applies to GFR, raceless markers are an ideal solution, but in lieu of ready access to these, I will continue to seek a nuanced understanding of how we can best estimate GFR in a manner that is based on robust evidence and doesn’t exacerbate health inequities.

18/
For many of the reasons made in these eloquent pieces (which I highly encourage reading), we feel that the rote documentation of race in the first line of the HPI is unlikely to serve a useful function and the practice of differential documentation offers potential for harm

19/
However, given the important implications related to structural racism and the potential that addressing race has in reducing health inequity, we suggest that race/ethnicity be documented as part of a complete social history, where it can be given appropriate context

20/20
@j_ikeme @RWGrantMD @RFRedberg @JAMAInternalMed @Adali_Mtz @brandon_s_scott @DestinyRoseman @Sarah_SchaeffMD @UCSFIMChiefs @CPSolvers @dereckwpaul @jbullockruns @AntiRacistUCSF @Neil_R_Powe @KBibbinsDomingo @tsaiduck77 @thegud_doc @Anand_Habib

More from Health

I think @SamAdlerBell in his quest to be the contrarian on Fauci gets several things wrong here. 1/


First, the failure last year actually was driven by the White House, the #Trump inner circle. Watch what's happening now, the US' scientific and public health infrastructure is creaking back to life. 2/

I think Sam underestimates the decimation of many of our health agencies over the past four years and the establishment of ideological control over them during the pandemic. 3/

I also am puzzled why Tony gets the blame for not speaking up, etc. Robert Redfield, Brett Giroir, Deb Birx, Jerome Adams, Alex Azar all could have done the same. 4/

Several of these people Bob Redfield, Brett Giroir, Alex Azar were led by craven ambition, Jerome Adams by cowardice, but I do think Deb Birx and Tony tried as institutionalists, insiders to make a difference. 5/
On 18.12.2020, computer engineer @FitTuber shared @YouTube video titled "10 Safe & Useful Ayurvedic Tablets to Replace Allopathic Pills (Instant Relief)". The drugs he promoted were by @baidyanathgroup, not sure if it was paid promotion. I bought them:
https://t.co/w6Sh2pMvJf


10 drugs, details, batch numbers R given in pic👇. All by @baidyanathgroup exept 1 by https://t.co/tg46sBhJr2
We did GCMSMS, ICP-OES and FTIR analyses on these samples. Here are my 10 safer modern medicine alternatives 2 @FitTuber's untested, potentially harmful #Ayurvedic drugs


Kanthsudharak Vati by Unjha Pharma
@FitTuber: 4 sorethroat, cold, cough
Analysis: Lead 0.54 mg/kg, Cadmium 0.4 mg/kg, Thallium 0.71 mg/kg and industrial phenols.
Low values, but not ideal.

Safe alternative: Levocetrizine & non-sedative cough syrup Levodropropizine


Baidyanath Rajbati
@Fittuber: for bloating, gas
Analysis:
Mercury 1.2 mg/kg
Arsenic 2.25 mg/kg
Male anabolic hormone - hydroxy testosterone+
Curcumin
Talc powder

Safer alternative: activated charcoal+simethicone (non-absorbed, no side effects) or short course esomeprazole.


Baidyanath Bilwadi Choorna
@Fittuber - 4 diarrhoea
Analysis
Thallium 3.68 mg/kg
[fun fact: 10-15 mg/kg is lethal dose for humans. Death can occur at lower dosages] https://t.co/9ozOKROhCK
Fenretinide - synthetic anti-cancer drug
Liver toxic chromium phosph.

Safer: Racecadotril

You May Also Like

Margatha Natarajar murthi - Uthirakosamangai temple near Ramanathapuram,TN
#ArudraDarisanam
Unique Natarajar made of emerlad is abt 6 feet tall.
It is always covered with sandal paste.Only on Thriuvadhirai Star in month Margazhi-Nataraja can be worshipped without sandal paste.


After removing the sandal paste,day long rituals & various abhishekam will be
https://t.co/e1Ye8DrNWb day Maragatha Nataraja sannandhi will be closed after anointing the murthi with fresh sandal paste.Maragatha Natarajar is covered with sandal paste throughout the year


as Emerald has scientific property of its molecules getting disturbed when exposed to light/water/sound.This is an ancient Shiva temple considered to be 3000 years old -believed to be where Bhagwan Shiva gave Veda gyaana to Parvati Devi.This temple has some stunning sculptures.
Trump is gonna let the Mueller investigation end all on it's own. It's obvious. All the hysteria of the past 2 weeks about his supposed impending firing of Mueller was a distraction. He was never going to fire Mueller and he's not going to


Mueller's officially end his investigation all on his own and he's gonna say he found no evidence of Trump campaign/Russian collusion during the 2016 election.

Democrats & DNC Media are going to LITERALLY have nothing coherent to say in response to that.

Mueller's team was 100% partisan.

That's why it's brilliant. NOBODY will be able to claim this team of partisan Democrats didn't go the EXTRA 20 MILES looking for ANY evidence they could find of Trump campaign/Russian collusion during the 2016 election

They looked high.

They looked low.

They looked underneath every rock, behind every tree, into every bush.

And they found...NOTHING.

Those saying Mueller will file obstruction charges against Trump: laughable.

What documents did Trump tell the Mueller team it couldn't have? What witnesses were withheld and never interviewed?

THERE WEREN'T ANY.

Mueller got full 100% cooperation as the record will show.