Lunchtime update from the Grenfell Tower Inquiry:

President of Arconic's French arm accepts customers were 'deliberately and dishonestly misled' over fire classification of cladding panels, as he is asked about email saying failed fire test must be kept 'VERY CONFIDENTIAL'

The most interesting point of this morning's evidence came right at the end of the session when Claude Schmidt was grilled about an email his colleague Claude Wehrle sent regarding the serious failure of polyethylene-cored ACM panels when bent into a cassette form in March 2010
Remember: Arconic in 2004/5 tested its ACM PE panel when bent into cassette and when bolted to a wall with rivets. The cassette version failed spectacularly, burning 10 times as fast. But Arconic dismissed this as a 'rogue result' and drew no distinction in its marketing...
... simply presenting the panel as a 'Class B' (the rating for the rivetted panel, and the required standard for many European countries). Skip forward to 2010, and this email chain.
Mr Wehrle, the firm's senior technical member of staff is told about a trend in Spain and Portugal where clients are demanding more fire resistant panels, and warned that with this type of panel "our prices are no longer in the market"
Mr Wehrle responds saying that he thinks this is because of the difference between cassette and riveted testing, notes that Reynobond PE in cassette doesn't obtain a Class B and says this should be kept "VERY CONFIDENTIAL!!!"
Millett, inquiry counsel, asks Schmidt: If Claude Wehrle genuinely believed the test on cassette to be a rogue result, he would have said so in this email? Yes
Asks if, in fact, Arconic knew cassette was not a Class B? Reading this email, yes, says Schmidt
"Do you accept that Arconic through Mr Wehrle knew that architects, designers, construction professionals were being misled by the claimed fire classification for cassette?"
"Yes."
"Do you accept that Arconic was deliberately and dishonestly misleading its customers about the claimed fire performance for the cassette variant of Reynobond PE 55?"
Long pause
"Well, in any case, regarding the B classification, I mean according to the Euro norm... yes"
A further email up the chain shows Wehrle's line manager Guy Scheidecker saying "this shouldn't even have been mentioned". Schmidt asked if this was ever reported to him. "No, I don't think so," he says.
"You would remember wouldn't you if you were told Arconic was perpertrating a deceit on it's customers. You would have remembered something like that, wouldn't you?"
"In theory, yes," says Schmidt.
Schmidt says he cannot explain how Scheidecker was "in on this" but he was not. Says he hasn't seen the emails before.

Much more discussed this morn, and I'll have a fuller report at the end of the day, but this felt like the most significant exchange.
(Note to any news editors who happen to be reading this thread: we've seen these emails before, it's Schmidt's answers about them that are the new bit)

More from Business

Should we go into the details of these 125 years?


SA is built on the exploitation of labour. That labour has functioned on alcohol unfortunately. Very few people consume liquor purely for enjoyment unfortunately. When SAB opened its doors 1895 workers were paid in alcohol- the dop/tot system. 2 years into SAB's establishment

The Prohibition Act is introduced. This means black people are barred from buying your wines, beer etc. So SAB's products are exclusively for white people. But during this period beer brewing by Black women is the norm. Ayinxilisi ncam ke this type of beer. Apparently it had some

Nutritious elements to it. Now some of the context around drinking culture during this time is migrant labour to the mines, further land dispossession, the Anglo-Boer Wars, Rhodes corruption (our first state capture commission if you will) which leads to his resignation.

This context plays a role in how our cities and small towns are constructed, how they lead to the confinement and surveillance yabantu. Traditional beer brewing is identified as a threat because buy now mining bosses have identified that there's money to be made here.

You May Also Like