Categories World
7 days
30 days
All time
Recent
Popular
THREAD: Numbers and Multiple Sources in Scripture.
Consider Judges 20’s battle narrative:
400,000 gathered Israelites,
700 Gibeahites defended by 26,000 Benjaminites,
22,000 Israelite casualties,
25,000 Benjaminite casualties, etc., etc.
Why all the numbers, Samuel?
In what follows, I’ll try to offer some suggestions.
(Image from deseret-dot-com.)
Judges 19’s narrative about a Levite and his concubine culminates in one of the bleakest and most horrific scenes in all of Scripture.
@DrPJWilliams has a thread on it (linked below), which is bigly
At the outset of ch. 20, ch. 19’s fallen Levite provides Israel with a highly one-sided version of events—one which says nothing at all about his betrayal/abandonment of his concubine,
and instead lays the blame for her death squarely at the feet of the men of Gibeah.
In response, the Israelites go to war against the Gibeahites, who are defended by their tribesmen, the Benjaminites.
To our surprise, however, the Israelites don’t fare very well.
Consider Judges 20’s battle narrative:
400,000 gathered Israelites,
700 Gibeahites defended by 26,000 Benjaminites,
22,000 Israelite casualties,
25,000 Benjaminite casualties, etc., etc.
Why all the numbers, Samuel?
In what follows, I’ll try to offer some suggestions.
(Image from deseret-dot-com.)
Judges 19’s narrative about a Levite and his concubine culminates in one of the bleakest and most horrific scenes in all of Scripture.
@DrPJWilliams has a thread on it (linked below), which is bigly
THREAD: The Bible\u2019s most gory story
— Peter J. Williams (@DrPJWilliams) August 19, 2019
It\u2019s the disturbing account of the rape & dissection of the Levite\u2019s concubine (Judges 19-21)
With lessons about male violence against women #vawg
At the outset of ch. 20, ch. 19’s fallen Levite provides Israel with a highly one-sided version of events—one which says nothing at all about his betrayal/abandonment of his concubine,
and instead lays the blame for her death squarely at the feet of the men of Gibeah.
In response, the Israelites go to war against the Gibeahites, who are defended by their tribesmen, the Benjaminites.
To our surprise, however, the Israelites don’t fare very well.
1. TTP is not a monolith and does not reside in one area in Afghanistan. Its connections with sections of the Afghan establishment and TTA are old and diverse. Dealing with TTP is part of the ongoing peace process and a key Pakistani demand.
2. Recent developments reveal these diverse & apparently contradictory connections of TTP. The mysterious killings of six mid-level TTP commanders b/n May & July in Afg was arguably the quid pro duo that Pak would have demanded in return for brokering the US-TB deal.
3. After these developments, among others, TTP reunified realizing that it'll be weakened if it didn't unify. While some sections of Afg establishment may ve links with Halqa Mehsud, after the 2014 APS attack it took action against the Swat Taliban.
4. Following the APS massacre, Afghan forces bombarded position of Fazlullah and his associates on Pakistan's insistence. In 2018, the Afghan ministry of defense officially announced Fazlullah's killing in a drone attack.
4. Going by @EUEofficial35's interview with @SaleemKhanSafi, Afghan establishment engaged factions of Jamaat-ul-Ahrar or the Mohmand Taliban. In the same interview, the allegations of Indian support were also leveled, including financial assistance and medical treatment.
Veteran Pakistani journalist @IKPeshawar reveals in a latest TV talk show hosted by @rifatorakzai that TTP was part of the agenda of the recent visit of Pakistani Prime Minister @ImranKhanPTI to Kabul. 1/3 https://t.co/lFwI53KmLU
— Ab. Sayed (@abdsayedd) January 9, 2021
2. Recent developments reveal these diverse & apparently contradictory connections of TTP. The mysterious killings of six mid-level TTP commanders b/n May & July in Afg was arguably the quid pro duo that Pak would have demanded in return for brokering the US-TB deal.
3. After these developments, among others, TTP reunified realizing that it'll be weakened if it didn't unify. While some sections of Afg establishment may ve links with Halqa Mehsud, after the 2014 APS attack it took action against the Swat Taliban.
4. Following the APS massacre, Afghan forces bombarded position of Fazlullah and his associates on Pakistan's insistence. In 2018, the Afghan ministry of defense officially announced Fazlullah's killing in a drone attack.
4. Going by @EUEofficial35's interview with @SaleemKhanSafi, Afghan establishment engaged factions of Jamaat-ul-Ahrar or the Mohmand Taliban. In the same interview, the allegations of Indian support were also leveled, including financial assistance and medical treatment.