Alex1Powell Categories Society
7 days
30 days
All time
Recent
Popular
I've made some allusions to how embarrassingly smug and lazy Kyle "I went to Yale" Smith's series is. We're two (short) posts in and it's still difficult to find substantive criticisms underneath an onslaught of purple prose and obvious contempt for community colleges.
The main allegations of his post are that Dr. Biden isn't a great writer and that she didn't do what Smith considers an adequate amount of work to justify her degree. It isn't shocking that he'd avoid substantive critique, as he lacks the expertise to make it.
In the paragraph below š, Smith takes Biden's citation pattern ā for a potted, perfunctory history of community colleges (which isn't intended to be anything else) ā as evidence that she couldn't be bothered to do the reading.
Did he bother to look at the books? At least check their tables of contents? One can find some basic information online. Cohen & Brawer (2003) appears to be a standard textbook on community colleges (cited 5400+ times). The page ranges reflect... relevant parts of the text.
I couldn't find a TOC with pagination for Witt et al., but here's a summary of the contents š. Again, given the substance the page ranges aren't terribly surprising, especially since she cites a different source for her *two sentences* on the pre-crash 1920s.
My first piece on Jill Biden\u2019s dissertation was just me getting warmed up. This gets into the substance and contains lots of direct quotation of her shockingly bad writing. https://t.co/VeA67VVhIf
— Kyle Smith (@rkylesmith) December 17, 2020
The main allegations of his post are that Dr. Biden isn't a great writer and that she didn't do what Smith considers an adequate amount of work to justify her degree. It isn't shocking that he'd avoid substantive critique, as he lacks the expertise to make it.
In the paragraph below š, Smith takes Biden's citation pattern ā for a potted, perfunctory history of community colleges (which isn't intended to be anything else) ā as evidence that she couldn't be bothered to do the reading.
Did he bother to look at the books? At least check their tables of contents? One can find some basic information online. Cohen & Brawer (2003) appears to be a standard textbook on community colleges (cited 5400+ times). The page ranges reflect... relevant parts of the text.
I couldn't find a TOC with pagination for Witt et al., but here's a summary of the contents š. Again, given the substance the page ranges aren't terribly surprising, especially since she cites a different source for her *two sentences* on the pre-crash 1920s.
Ok #ygk, I have a serious thread coming to end this series.
Part 3 of 3 focuses on what happens to people after they turn away from the church.
Most said they were shunned, excommunicated, and defamed by their former friends, even by some of their family members when they left.
In part 1, I described how peopleās whole lives played out at the church.
https://t.co/TiqrkjJONI
After leaving, they had to relearn how to live.
They never listened āsecularā music or watched certain movies, some were even told to boycott Starbucks, because it supports Pride
Going back into the "real world" made one former member feel like she was "losing her mind."
Also, part 3 shows the extreme fear that some people had after leaving.
One person said she worried she would literally be struck by lighting if she spoke badly about the church. #ygk
Part 3 of 3 focuses on what happens to people after they turn away from the church.
Most said they were shunned, excommunicated, and defamed by their former friends, even by some of their family members when they left.
Former members of a #ygk church say its leader, known as "Apostle,\u201d promised them miracles, but instead they were traumatized.
— Global Kingston (@CKWS_TV) December 17, 2020
As faith communities like these grow, the former members are calling for oversight of independent, charismatic churches.https://t.co/eVnG52dBcm
In part 1, I described how peopleās whole lives played out at the church.
https://t.co/TiqrkjJONI
After leaving, they had to relearn how to live.
They never listened āsecularā music or watched certain movies, some were even told to boycott Starbucks, because it supports Pride
Going back into the "real world" made one former member feel like she was "losing her mind."
Also, part 3 shows the extreme fear that some people had after leaving.
One person said she worried she would literally be struck by lighting if she spoke badly about the church. #ygk