This is not acceptable. A scientist cannot make a public claim of discovering something that s/he knows had already been discovered by others. I know it is obvious but that is exactly what happened in this press release of @theDESurvey @fermilab

@theDESurvey @Fermilab +..
The lead author, Yuanyuan Zhang, claims that "we discovered that intracluster light is a pretty good radial tracer of dark matter", which sounds awfully similar to...+
@theDESurvey @Fermilab +... this 2019 paper by Mireia Montes and Ignacio Trujillo (MT19) "Intracluster light: a luminous tracer for dark matter in clusters of galaxies" ...+

https://t.co/lzZ0KnPUB7
@theDESurvey @Fermilab +...Could it be that the authors were not aware of the MT19 work? No. I mean, it's not like MT19 was an obscure paper published in a small journal 30 years ago. It was published last year in one of the top astronomy journals... AND... +
@theDESurvey @Fermilab +...AND... NASA made a press release about it:

https://t.co/yJ3crQjWwT

That in addition to their home institution @IAC_Astrofisica press release:
https://t.co/yb60Mws5Cg

...+
@theDESurvey @Fermilab @IAC_Astrofisica +...
The MT19 paper was all over the science media ...+
@theDESurvey @Fermilab @IAC_Astrofisica +.. There's no question that the authors were well aware of the MT19 paper because IT IS PROPERLY CREDITED IN THEIR TWO PAPERS. Here are some screenshots from both papers...+
@theDESurvey @Fermilab @IAC_Astrofisica +...In fact, the second paper says that "we further explore this connection" (see attached screenshot). So how does one go from "providing additional evidence" and "further exploring [a] connection" to "we have discovered that"??? ...+
@theDESurvey @Fermilab @IAC_Astrofisica +...We're told all the time that scientists need to overstate the importance of their results in a press release, or explain it in a way that the public can grasp the impact of the research. Look, I'm not saying this work is not important. It is! But this PR is not acceptable...+
@theDESurvey @Fermilab @IAC_Astrofisica +...We cannot lie to the public and that's what's happened here. I don't know whose fault it is. Exaggerated headlines or bad press releases are often blamed on the journalist who wrote them. But in the institutions I know, ...+
@theDESurvey @Fermilab @IAC_Astrofisica +..the lead scientist is ultimately responsible for the contents of a press release. Furthermore, Zhang's quote is "we discovered..."...+
@theDESurvey @Fermilab @IAC_Astrofisica +...In my opinion, it is dishonest to oversell one's achievements in a PR. The discovery that ICL traces dark matter was done by Montes and Trujillo, as is correctly stated in the scientific papers. The public should not be told a different story.

PS: Montes is @mireiamontesq
@theDESurvey @Fermilab @IAC_Astrofisica @mireiamontesq cc @emulenews @El_Lobo_Rayado @cienciabrujula @SaraRC83 @GastonGiribet @joseedelstein @DarkSapiens @radioskylab_es @StartsWithABang

More from Society

The Nashville Operation - A Battle in the War

A thread exploring the Nashville bombing in the context of the 2020 Digital War (via SolarWinds) against the United States perpetrated by our enemies, likely China, Iran and/or Russia.


SolarWinds Hack

A digital "Pearl Harbor" moment for the United States, whoever was responsible had access to the keys to the kingdom for months during 2020, including sensitive military infrastructure. This is war!

SunGard + SolarWinds

SolarWinds software company is owned by same company that owns SunGard, which essentially provides data center services. A secure place to host internet servers with redundant power and "big pipe" data connections.

https://t.co/U3P3SrrkM1


SunGard Data Center

In Nashville, around the corner from their "big pipe" connection, AT&T. Like any data center, highly secure. Only authorized personnel can enter, and even fewer can access the actual server rooms. Backup generators are available in case of power failure.


If the SunGard hardware was being used to "host" critical command and control software related to SolarWinds, the US powers would be very interested in gaining special access keys that are stored on the hard-drives of specific servers.
A long thread on how an obsessive & violent antisemite & Holocaust denier has been embraced by the international “community of the good.”

Sarah Wilkinson has a history of Holocaust denial & anti-Jewish hatred dating back (in documented examples) to around 2015.


She is a self-proclaimed British activist for “Palestinian rights” but is more accurately a far Left neo-Nazi. Her son shares the same characteristics of violence, racism & Holocaust denial.

I first documented Sarah Wilkinson’s Holocaust denial back in July 2016. I believe I was the 1st person to do so.

Since then she has produced a long trail of written hate and abuse. See here for a good summary.


Wilkinson has recently been publicly celebrated by @XRebellionUK over her latest violent action against a Jewish owned business. Despite many people calling XR’s attention to her history, XR have chosen to remain in alliance with this neo-Nazi.

Former Labour Shadow Chancellor John McDonnell MP is among those who also chose to stand with Wilkinson via a tweet.

But McDonnell is not alone.

Neo-Nazi Sarah Wilkinson is supported and encouraged by thousands of those on the Left who consider themselves “anti-racists”.

You May Also Like