Rereading Asad Haider's Mistaken Identity recently, I was struck by this bit: "single-issue political frameworks ... end up centering the most privileged members of a group, marginalizing those whose identities exposed them to other forms of subordination."

It articulated something I personally have been trying to for a while now: that Jewish people to whom the single defining issue of 2019 was Labour antisemitism were not people who really *needed* a Labour government, whose life depended on an end to Tory rule.
A number of Jewish people I know – Jews living in poverty, Jews of colour – were concerned by what was happening in Labour. But quite simply, they couldn't guarantee their survival under the Tories. There was no question of who had their vote in a 2-horse race.
These people were appalled that Labour AS, serious as it was, was seen as sufficient reason to elect a party that, to them, was unspeakably worse. But it's hardly surprising: for the Jewish people advocating for "anyone but Labour", life under the Tories isn't much different.
Reading Haider, it becomes clear to me that those for whom antisemitism was the make-or-break issue at an election that took place after Grenfell, years of a hostile environment, a decade of austerity, probably did not personally have much to lose.
When David Baddiel and Hadley Freeman and Marie Van Der Zyl complain that "no other minority would be treated this way", they are telling on themselves: they have no knowledge or experience of oppression beyond this issue. Many other minorities are treated this way, and worse.

More from All

You May Also Like

THREAD: 12 Things Everyone Should Know About IQ

1. IQ is one of the most heritable psychological traits – that is, individual differences in IQ are strongly associated with individual differences in genes (at least in fairly typical modern environments). https://t.co/3XxzW9bxLE


2. The heritability of IQ *increases* from childhood to adulthood. Meanwhile, the effect of the shared environment largely fades away. In other words, when it comes to IQ, nature becomes more important as we get older, nurture less.
https://t.co/UqtS1lpw3n


3. IQ scores have been increasing for the last century or so, a phenomenon known as the Flynn effect. https://t.co/sCZvCst3hw (N ≈ 4 million)

(Note that the Flynn effect shows that IQ isn't 100% genetic; it doesn't show that it's 100% environmental.)


4. IQ predicts many important real world outcomes.

For example, though far from perfect, IQ is the single-best predictor of job performance we have – much better than Emotional Intelligence, the Big Five, Grit, etc. https://t.co/rKUgKDAAVx https://t.co/DWbVI8QSU3


5. Higher IQ is associated with a lower risk of death from most causes, including cardiovascular disease, respiratory disease, most forms of cancer, homicide, suicide, and accident. https://t.co/PJjGNyeQRA (N = 728,160)
I'm going to do two history threads on Ethiopia, one on its ancient history, one on its modern story (1800 to today). 🇪🇹

I'll begin with the ancient history ... and it goes way back. Because modern humans - and before that, the ancestors of humans - almost certainly originated in Ethiopia. 🇪🇹 (sub-thread):


The first likely historical reference to Ethiopia is ancient Egyptian records of trade expeditions to the "Land of Punt" in search of gold, ebony, ivory, incense, and wild animals, starting in c 2500 BC 🇪🇹


Ethiopians themselves believe that the Queen of Sheba, who visited Israel's King Solomon in the Bible (c 950 BC), came from Ethiopia (not Yemen, as others believe). Here she is meeting Solomon in a stain-glassed window in Addis Ababa's Holy Trinity Church. 🇪🇹


References to the Queen of Sheba are everywhere in Ethiopia. The national airline's frequent flier miles are even called "ShebaMiles". 🇪🇹