So I'm not the first, & won't be the last, to be irked by this. But anyway, here goes.

What Murph's reporting (& opining) on is a survey that showed, in a time of international crisis where Australia has performed relatively well, politicians benefit from a "competence dividend"

That's neither a surprise, nor something to be sneered at. But it's a one-paragraph story. It's what you'd expect to see.

The journalist's role, you'd think, would be to critically unpick that. Work through what premiers & the PM did to deserve it, or otherwise.
One case that could be made is that the premiers stepped up, acted visibly & decisively on behalf of their respective states, & the PM is largely riding on their coattails.

Murph, though, has been on a weird campaign to position Morrison in particular as a statesman-in-waiting.
Once the federal government authorised Job Seeker/Lover/Keeper, Murph was convinced this was (bound to be) the end of Ideological Warrior Morrison and we'd see the emergence of pragmatic Morrison who could govern reasonably, in ways atypical of the way his party had been trending
LOL

And LOL again.

The early economic interventions were made with a gun to his head. The idea he'd suddenly become a learning learner who learns was something Murph seemed desperate to hold on to, like it was important for her sense that federal politics could work properly.
The interesting thing (to me) from the state perspective was how immune premiers were from (i) their own missteps and (ii) attacks by a hostile press, in some cases.

That they stood up in public, and achieved results, however clumsily, was what mattered.
I mean, we can all see what's happening in other countries as deaths mount and harsh lockdowns occur (or don't, with deaths mounting faster). Australia's a success story, and credit will occur.

There are multiple stories behind that success. Murph barely even hints at them.
I mean, we could pick apart individual premiers' responses, and make the obvious point that they win by "acting tough", relative to the actual competence and proportionality of their respective technocratic (public health) and legal (political) responses. This is fascinating.
It's also important. One can view those two arms of the response as a see-saw of sorts; the worse the public health response is, the more/harsher the political measures need to be.

Capable journalists should work through this. NSW Health have been stunning through this.
But the "faith in politics" narrative here is offset by a perception that conflates public health and political responses -- put simply, Gladys "should be doing more" (mandating and locking down), or worse, that NSW are somehow fudging numbers for political purposes.
I think this is mostly a brain-addlement of social media; meaning, most people not terminally online don't think NSW is doing a bad job, and a lot of the criticism of NSW's response comes from out-of-staters stull jumpy from the long lockdowns they endured.

But still.
Commentators should be emphasising the fact that strong political responses are a sign that your technocratic (public health) response is inadequate/overwhelmed.

Trust-in-politics surveys will tend to elide these distinctions. Those with a platform should highlight them.
Now to the feds. Morrison has mostly done one thing, at least visibly. He's thrown money out when it was desperately needed, and in circumstances where he was being advised from all sides that this was needed to avoid calamity. It's pretty clear he wants to revert to type asap.
(However much Murph wishes/hopes otherwise.)

You'd think something the feds have carriage over--the rollout of vaccines--would be in Murph's line of sight, as well as other commentators. This is going to be the single biggest test of their competence going forward.
If Murph cannot bring herself to say that it's possible that the competence dividend Morrison has benefitted from is in large part a result of riding the premiers' collective coat-tails, and that his biggest test of competence is yet to come, then what value is her commentary?
Seriously, why do we have a commentator class that just runs past the substance, INCLUDING those that sometimes on a Sunday morning Insiders' chair complain about the gallery's focus on the horse-race and the optics?

I don't know if we deserve better, but we desperately need it.
@threadreaderapp please unroll

More from Politics

All the challenges to Leader Pelosi are coming from her right, in an apparent effort to make the party even more conservative and bent toward corporate interests.

Hard pass. So long as Leader Pelosi remains the most progressive candidate for Speaker, she can count on my support.


I agree that our party should, and must, evolve our leadership.

But changed leadership should reflect an actual, evolved mission; namely, an increased commitment to the middle + working class electorate that put us here.

Otherwise it’s a just new figure with the same problems.

I hope that we can move swiftly to conclude this discussion about party positions, so that we can spend more time discussing party priorities: voting rights, healthcare, wages, climate change, housing, cannabis legalization, good jobs, etc.
Handy guide for Dominic Raab and other Brexiteers, and for anyone keen to replace our EU trade with trade with the rest of the world on WTO terms...


You can't magic away the vast distances involved. Clue: we fly in only 1/192th of our trade compared to the amount that arrives via sea


But even if you invented a teleporter tomorrow, WTO terms are so bad, so stacked against us, that a no-deal Brexit will be a total economic disaster


And while the Brexiteers fantasise, real jobs are being lost, investments are drying up, companies are moving assets to the EU27 or redomiciling. All already happened and happening right now, not in some mythical


Of course, there are many, many myths that Brexiteers perpetuate that are total fiction. You've seen a couple of them already. The thread below busts a whole lot
This idea - that elections should translate into policy - is not wrong at all. But political science can help explain why it's not working this way. There are three main explanations: 1. mandates are constructed, not automatic, 2. party asymmetry, 3. partisan conpetition 1/


First, party/policy mandates from elections are far from self-executing in our system. Work on mandates from Dahl to Ellis and Kirk on the history of the mandate to mine on its role in post-Nixon politics, to Peterson Grossback and Stimson all emphasize that this link is... 2/

Created deliberately and isn't always persuasive. Others have to convinced that the election meant a particular thing for it to work in a legislative context. I theorized in the immediate period of after the 2020 election that this was part of why Repubs signed on to ...3/

Trump's demonstrably false fraud nonsense - it derailed an emerging mandate news cycle. Winners of elections get what they get - institutional control - but can't expect much beyond that unless the perception of an election mandate takes hold. And it didn't. 4/

Let's turn to the legislation element of this. There's just an asymmetry in terms of passing a relief bill. Republicans are presumably less motivated to get some kind of deal passed. Democrats are more likely to want to do *something.* 5/

You May Also Like