I posted this elsewhere on social media today. Sharing here because I think there are many ppl who relate, and bc having gotten pushback again today, I have found further reason for hope in some of the support I’ve gotten (thread): 1/11

In all of the pushback I’ve gotten over the past yr in statements I’ve made about politics & the white evangelical church, notably a lot has been not about the substance of my message but a continual refrain of “why do you have to say ‘white’ Christians?” 2/11
I’ll share a little to explain why this stands out to me. I’m Indian-American, loosely defined. My dad is from India and my mom is white. I have enjoyed all the privilege of living as a white American, to be clear (lots to unpack there, but have to save that for another day) 3/11
My entire life I’ve been asked to explain myself. “Where are you from?” “Ohio.” “But where are you *really* from?” Or worse, “what *are* you?” I grew up in the 80s and 90s and this is my lived experience. I now know it’s a common one for others like me. 4/11
Again, much more to unpack here, but the point is: I was always “other” because I wasn’t white.

White is just assumed as this default that we have lived with in America, and everyone else has then of course had to be named as something else: black, Hispanic, brown, etc 5/11
So when we suddenly see white being named, I can honestly understand why it would throw people off. If you’ve always just BEEN, without having been forced to define yourself, then you just assume you are the default, and why is everyone suddenly using terms like “whiteness”?6/11
Just because we are now using the word white in talking about subsets of people does not mean it is pejorative. Its just our language for describing people & always has been. White people are just not used to seeing it, and I get that can be jarring. 7/11
All I am really saying is this: if you are white, the next time you see “white” as a descriptor in front of a group (white church, white evangelicals, etc), consider that while it is jarring, it is how so many of us have lived our entire lives- having to explain ourselves.8/11
Its not a demand that you explain yourself - I know that’s tiring. But I am also tired of constantly being asked “why do you have to say ‘white?’” 9/11
I say it because it is an accurate descriptor. And if it offends you, please consider that this is the position many of us have been put in all along. 10/11
After posting all that and getting negative comments, I finally decided to press play on @austinchanning ‘s “I’m Still Here,” which I downloaded on Audible months ago. And then I cried at the end of the 1st chapter. V grateful for others leading in this space, at great risk /end

More from For later read

Every single public defender. Every single day.


Bail arguments, motions, oral arguments, hearings. Judges don’t know, follow, or care about the law. Prosecutors are willing to take advantage of it. And mandatory minimums, withheld evidence, & pretrial detention coerces people to plead before trial. When theres a jury. A shot.

But defenders still fight. And still win. Most times wins aren’t “Justice.” It’s power of repetition of argument in front of same judges. Introducing those in power to the people they oppress. Not just a RAP sheet or words on a page. Defenders make it harder to be brutal & cruel.

I worked as a public defender at an office as well resourced as any in the country. Social workers, team of investigators, a reentry team, support staff, specialist attorneys in immigration, housing, education, family. Relatively low caseloads (80-100). And yet still injustice.

Most think that balancing the scales of justice means more funding for defenders. Thats part of it. Enough a attorneys to actually be at bail hearings. Wrap around services to be able to help people trapped in the system end up better off in their communities. Lower caseloads.

You May Also Like