Victory for journalists, press freedom after tribunal finds there is no reason to bar people from using the UK's freedom of information act simply because they are not in the UK. @SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas

The decision comes after the First-Tier tribunal stayed 16 Freedom of Information by appeals by journalists and ordinary people, because they were either not UK citizens, or had UK nationality but were living abroad. @SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
Today's decision means that the Freedom of Information Act will continue to operate as it always has done for the past 15 years. It is open to any person regardless of nationality or place of residence.@SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
Upper Tribunal judge O’Connor said today:" We found there is no territorial limitation that should be read into FOIA." Reasons will be given later. @SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
The decision means that after long delays - and arguably unnecessary - delays a number of important public interest FOIA requests can now resume. @SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
Italian journalist Stefania Maurizi can now continue her appeal against the Metropolitan Police for refusing to disclose its correspondence with the US about three UK-based journalists involved in WikiLeaks.@SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
The French investigative journalist Emmanuel Freudenthal, who lives in Kenya, is seeking disclosures about thousands of Ebola-infected blood samples taken from people in Sierra Leone without their consent. @SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
Ben Lucas, a financial crime journalist, had is Freedom of Information appeal stayed because he moved to Hong Kong for his work, on the grounds that he was no longer resident in the UK.@SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
Mohamed Mohamood Abdullah joined the tribunal from a computer link in Somalia. He had been using FOIA to seek the service record of his British farther who served in the Royal Navy, and was wounded in action.@SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
The tribunal had put Mohamed's case on hold because he made his FOIA request outside the UK. Now he will be free to continue his search for his father's military records. @SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
Estelle Dehon, barrister for Maurizi told the tribunal of the harm that blocking overseas FOIA requests would have on the accountability of government departments, openness of government and democracy. @SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
She said that journalists had been recognised by the courts as 'democratic watchdogs,' and that the Information Commissioner recognises the importance of FOIA in combating fake news and increasing trust @SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
Investigative journalism of the nature undertaken by Maurizi and Lucas is based on documentary sources, and #FOIA is an important route to accessing documents.@SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
The output of overseas journalists work is consumed both outside the UK and inside the UK, said Dehon. SMaurizi @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
"It is inexplicable why a journalist could be permitted to make a FOIA request stuck halfway across that channel on the Eurostar but not at her desk at home or a desk in Hong Kong or Nairobi"@estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
Ms Maurizi had brought FOI litigation in Sweden, the US and Australia, said Dehon."Never has one response come back you were not in jurisdiction so your request was not a proper one." @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
The tribunal recognised what has been accepted for the past 15 years, that FOIA is 'applicant blind.' @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
If the tribunal had ruled that only UK citizens could use the FOIA act, that would present huge administrative burdens to public authorities in the UK, the tribunal heard.@estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
People would have to provide documents and evidence to government departments when they filed FOIA requests, and give oral evidence on their nationality when they made an appeal. @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
And non-British citizens, like Mr Abdullah who is seeking his father's military records from Somalia, would have to produce documents and evidence to show that they have enough connection to the UK to appeal to the tribunal. @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
What is unusual about the case is that no one has at any time argued that the people outside the UK should be excluded from using FOIA. The Information Commissioner, the Home Office, and all the FOIA applicants agreed this.@estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
The argument began with the first tier tribunal itself questioning its jurisdiction under FOIA. @estelledehon @EmmanFre @benjameslucas #FOIA
More later, but here is the backstory:
https://t.co/cAJqtm1hYS

More from Government

Labour Grandees are listed in Sir Keir Starmer's colleague Jeffrey Epstein's ''Little Black Book''; Blair, Mandelson and Alastair Campbell. COINCIDENTLY, Keir Starmer and some of the same people have connections to ANOTHER of the worlds most prolific peadophiles. #StarmerOut


Starmer failed to bring charges against Jimmy Savile for paedophilia. The decision was made despite the Crown Prosecution Service receiving substantial evidence of his crimes from witnesses and victims several years before Savile died in 2011. #StarmerOut
https://t.co/PNyX5uSAkw


With a past like hers, Margaret Hodge might show a bit more humility.
In the Eighties Hodge was aware of previous child sex abuse in the care homes for which she was responsible, and did nothing about it. #LabourLeaks #StarmerOut

As leader of Islington Council, a post she held from 1982-92, Margaret Hodge was aware of previous, horrendous child sex abuse in the care homes for which she was responsible, and did nothing about it. #LabourLeaks #StarmerOut #CSA

She was guilty of rather more than a casual failure of oversight. In an open letter to the BBC after it investigated a range of monstrous abuse (child prostitution, torture, alleged murders), Hodge libelled one of its victims as “seriously disturbed”. #LabourLeaks #StarmerOut
If you're curious what Trump's defense will look like, all you have to do is turn on Fox News. My latest at @mmfa

The tl;dr is that for years right-wing media have been excusing Trump's violent rhetoric by going, "Yes, but THE DEMOCRATS..." and then bending themselves into knots to pretend that Dems were calling for violence when they very, very clearly weren't.

And in fact, this predates Trump.

In 2008, Obama was talking about not backing down in the face of an ugly campaign. He said "If they bring a knife to the fight, we bring a gun."

https://t.co/i5YaQJsKop


That quote was from the movie The Untouchables. And there's no way anybody reading that quote in good faith could conclude that he was talking about actual guns and knives. But it became a big talking point on the

In 2018, Obama-era Attorney General Eric Holder was speaking to a group of Georgia Democrats about GOP voter suppression. He riffed on Michelle Obama's "When they go low, we go high" line from the 2016 DNC.

You May Also Like