Several people asked me to say something about this rather fantastical claim, that SARS-CoV-2 might already have been lurking in Barcelona sewers in March 2019.
TLDR: There is no solid evidence for this, just a possible false-positive/cross reactive RT-PCR. /

The link that Reuters provided in their tweet is not working, but here is the correct link:
https://t.co/kY4CWLkytG
It is not a simple press release, but appears to have involved several journalists doing an investigation.
The Reuters article does mention that the results might be a bit preliminary. A scientist not involved with the study is quoted saying that it was "early to draw definitive conclusions". The authors however appear convinced that the finding was true.
So let's take a look at the preprint. This study has not been peer reviewed. It is a preprint on MedRxiv, so it needs to be interpreted this with extreme caution.
Reuters does not provide the link (why not?) but I did the searching for you. Here:
https://t.co/IIURYwkXbM
The study's initial intent was to see if the virus could be detected in Barcelona wastewater during the COVID-19 outbreak in early 2020, and it was indeed found starting in Jan 2020. That is cool, because wastewater screening is a nice surveillance method to sample a whole city.
But then, the authors looked at some older samples, and one of these, from March 2019 (a year before the first COVID-19 cases in the city) appeared to be positive.
It was just one sample, though, and it does not appear that the authors repeated the test at all. No replicates as far as I can tell.
But also note that only 2 of the 5 RT-PCR tests were positive, i.e. on the IP2 and IP4 genes.
Now, I am not a viral gene specialist, but I do know that some SARS-CoV-2 PCRs can give false positives. Even the WHO protocol, followed by the Barcelona group, states that IP2/IP4 cross-reactivity with other viruses can occur.
https://t.co/QliEutF5Ga
But the authors did not do any other target PCRs, or (even better) genomic sequencing. They did not do any confirmation to rule out cross-reactivity with some other virus.
This is why peer review is so important. Yes, peer review has many flaws, but it is better than nothing.
Without peer review, researchers might draw preliminary or incorrect conclusions. We all love our own data. But other researchers' critical reading is needed to find flaws.
A paper that makes a fantastic claim has to have fantastic data.
This is not the case here.
The authors need much more than just 2 positive PCRs to prove their claim. They need to provide e.g. a genomic sequence and absolutely rule out a contamination with a 2020 sample.

More from All

You May Also Like

I'm going to do two history threads on Ethiopia, one on its ancient history, one on its modern story (1800 to today). 🇪🇹

I'll begin with the ancient history ... and it goes way back. Because modern humans - and before that, the ancestors of humans - almost certainly originated in Ethiopia. 🇪🇹 (sub-thread):


The first likely historical reference to Ethiopia is ancient Egyptian records of trade expeditions to the "Land of Punt" in search of gold, ebony, ivory, incense, and wild animals, starting in c 2500 BC 🇪🇹


Ethiopians themselves believe that the Queen of Sheba, who visited Israel's King Solomon in the Bible (c 950 BC), came from Ethiopia (not Yemen, as others believe). Here she is meeting Solomon in a stain-glassed window in Addis Ababa's Holy Trinity Church. 🇪🇹


References to the Queen of Sheba are everywhere in Ethiopia. The national airline's frequent flier miles are even called "ShebaMiles". 🇪🇹
THE MEANING, SIGNIFICANCE AND HISTORY OF SWASTIK

The Swastik is a geometrical figure and an ancient religious icon. Swastik has been Sanatan Dharma’s symbol of auspiciousness – mangalya since time immemorial.


The name swastika comes from Sanskrit (Devanagari: स्वस्तिक, pronounced: swastik) &denotes “conducive to wellbeing or auspicious”.
The word Swastik has a definite etymological origin in Sanskrit. It is derived from the roots su – meaning “well or auspicious” & as meaning “being”.


"सु अस्ति येन तत स्वस्तिकं"
Swastik is de symbol through which everything auspicios occurs

Scholars believe word’s origin in Vedas,known as Swasti mantra;

"🕉स्वस्ति ना इन्द्रो वृधश्रवाहा
स्वस्ति ना पूषा विश्ववेदाहा
स्वस्तिनास्तरक्ष्यो अरिश्तनेमिही
स्वस्तिनो बृहस्पतिर्दधातु"


It translates to," O famed Indra, redeem us. O Pusha, the beholder of all knowledge, redeem us. Redeem us O Garudji, of limitless speed and O Bruhaspati, redeem us".

SWASTIK’s COSMIC ORIGIN

The Swastika represents the living creation in the whole Cosmos.


Hindu astronomers divide the ecliptic circle of cosmos in 27 divisions called
https://t.co/sLeuV1R2eQ this manner a cross forms in 4 directions in the celestial sky. At centre of this cross is Dhruva(Polestar). In a line from Dhruva, the stars known as Saptarishi can be observed.