BC CULTURE
Saved by @Mollyycolllinss

I ran across a quote a long time ago, and it's stuck with me:

“Never, ever, think about something else when you should be thinking about the power of incentives.”
— Charlie Munger

 This talk is both in transcript form and there's a YouTube audio of it as well. https://t.co/1nSU8aS3tC
I like this quote from Munger:

"I think I’ve been in the top 5% of my age cohort all my life in understanding the power of incentives, and all my life I’ve underestimated it. And never a year passes, but I get some surprise that pushes my limit a little farther."
So now, like a mad monkey who has just discovered the hammer, I will now go around using this tool of incentives and perverse incentives on everything. Maybe I'll get lucky and hit a few actual nails.
At root, I think the riots at the capitol are the result of a synergy of perverse incentives in politics, mass media, and social media, and they all contribute to a perfect storm of dysfunction. Maybe this is obvious to everyone, and I'm just catching up. But whatever. Here goes.
In politics, the perverse incentive is a result of gerrymanding. What was once considered a useful tool for keeping the opposing party out of power has now become a straitjacket of radicalization. The wingnuts challenging the election are doing b/c they fear being primaried....
... they no longer have heterogeneous districts with a wide spectrum of viewpoints, they have exquisitely crafted districts that keep anyone with a different viewpoint muffled and distant, so they are now only responsive to the interests of their narrow political tribe...
...this wouldn't be so terrible, except that this tribe is getting all of its information from another set of actors who are also working according to perverse incentives. Fox News, and to some extent all the news stations are driven by profit, and the thing that drives profit...
...is viewership. And the thing that drives viewership is emotion. So the more you stoke fear, rage, righteousness, superiority, disgust, etc. the more watchers you get. The actual news on Fox News doesn't get anywhere near the views that it's opinion shows get, because...
...the actual news panders less than the opinion side. Pandering works. Stoking people's emotions works. It gets views and therefore ad dollars. Fox is great at this. They're top rated. So they've got a real profit incentive to keep stoking rage...
...Similarly, the hosts of these shows have an incentive to keep stoking those emotions. Hannity makes something like $40 million/year. Over on talk radio Limbaugh makes $80m/yr. I think poor Tucker only makes $10m/yr. Sad Panda, as my son says. Regardless, for any human these...
...incentives are huge. This cannot help but affect behaviors. This was the root concept I was playing with when I wrote "American Gold Mine." The problem is that Fox has established itself as the center of "conservative" news, delivering a product counter to the "liberal MSM"...
...so almost by definition, they have to contest whatever is said in the rest of the press, which has been thoroughly delegitimized to its viewers over time. So as soon as they start saying something like "Dominion Voting Machines weren't actually fraudulent" their viewership...
...revolts and flees to another station that will pander to them more. So Fox has to return to the pandering to get their viewers back. This is largely a self-inflicted wound. By deligitimizing all news reported on the "MSM"...
...It means that Fox's actual brand/product must always be "FUCK YOU MSM." That's the product that its viewers have developed a taste for, and if they change the product, they don't like it. No one likes it when you buy Cheerios, and Corn Flakes pours out of the box....
So now you have two problems. You have gerrymandered districts, and within those districts you have constituents who are fed an unrelieved propaganda diet that says the "MSM" is wrong/traitorous/liberal/etc...
So now you have two perverse incentives to pander. Fox et al need to pander for profit, and can't stop pandering because their brand is entirely oppositionally defined against whatever the rest of the world is saying (ie reality), and you have politicians trying to get elected...
...or reelected and they need to pander to that same audience that has been cynically and profitably fed its monotonous and rageful diet of "news opinion." So politicians in these gerrymandered districts, if they want to hold office, stoke the lies...
...Slavoj Zizek once described a phenomenon where people deflect things that undermine their good opinion of themselves (anyone can fall victim to this, not just conservatives, btw). He describes it thus:

"I know. But I don't want to know. So I don't know."

(cont...)
... I think the power of perverse incentives is so strong that, except for a few cases who are clearly morons or lunatics, Republican elected officials cannot come to grips with the lies they're perpetuating. They know, but they don't want to know, so they don't know...
... and we know these incentives are powerful, because even in the face of overwhelming evidence, we see republicans making false statements both about the election, and about the President's culpability and impeachability for causing a seditious riot...
So, gerrymandered districts, consuming a steady diet of disinformation. But I don't think the riots could have happened if not for social media and the perverse incentives within it... Obviously, Facebook has a perverse incentive to increase "engagement" which means...
...giving people steady jolts of dopamine and adrenaline. Stoking their emotions. Making them angry, making them share, making their friends engage, stoking their sense of righteousness and superiority. Not just for rightwingers. For all of us... so we all get the information...
...that Facebook's algorithms tell it will stoke us best, and it feeds it back to us again and again and again. So already, Facebook and all the other social media companies--anyone who calibrates their news feeds--is explicitly more interested in engagement...
...engagement is profitable. Truth isn't necessarily profitable. Nor decency. Nor kindness. There are no human values behind the algorithms. There is only engagement. Rage posting about how liberals are traitors is more valuable than that photo you took of your dinner....
...but it's not just social media responding to the perverse incentives. We ourselves are responding. We get drug rushes every time we post. Every time someone replies. Every time someone shares. Or likes. So not only are the algorithms tuning for engagement, so are we...
... and that means that we learn what our audience likes and responds to, and we, addicted animals that we are, do more of that, like rats poking our noses at the button for another sugar pill. We become more animated, more certain, more vicious, more performative...
For the sake of likes, we radicalize ourselves.
...I've watched this happen within my communities. I've watched decent people become indecent. I've watched myself and my own physical reactions to likes and replies and shares, those brain chemistry jolts that keep me coming back for more.

Social media: It's a helluva drug.
... So, perverse incentives. We have politicians who can't say the truth, because their constituents are gerrymandered and only consume a narrow diet of entertainment-news/disinformation, given to them for profit by media companies, which they then share with their friends...
...online, which Facebook other social media companies then serve up to more people who will engage with the news/disinformation/info-drug in order to maximize profits, and then the users themselves, in pursuit of more dopamine hits will amplify and radicalize their own words...
... and eventually you stoke all those engines enough, and fuel them enough, and make them echo enough, say, with a President who himself is addicted to the hit of social media and has 80 million followers, and finally you get riots and sedition...
...but not just riots and sedition, but riots and sedition done by people who have become so encased in disinformation that they cannot comprehend that they are criminal. All the perverse incentives synergize, and in the end, you get radicalized fundamentalist Americans.
It's like a recipe. Take decent people. Isolate their information. Create feedback loops. Watch shit explode.

And if you're a media or social media company, of course... Profit.
Christ, I do go on, don't I?

More from Culture

Maurice Casey
Maurice Casey
@MauriceJCasey
I am reading through reams of late-1920s communist poetry and easily my favourite title so far is: "To a Lady who Rejected a Poem about Spring as a Petit-Bourgeois Deviation"

The last lines:
"So here's my hat into the air,
Three cheers for your amazing hair,
For coal mines, and for turbines, too,
For steel, the Comintern and you!"

A not exactly graceful (though possibly satirical) title: "Lines Disassociating Myself from Yessenin and Supporting the Otherwise Unfounded Legend that I am a Foremost Proletarian Writer"

An excerpt:
"Goodbye verses of Yessenin
Goodbye literary slop-
You are not the line of Lenin
You are not the line of WAPP

Never shall I moan a
simple lyric from the heart
I'll devote my new corona
to the proletarian art"

The poet was Joseph Freeman, who published much of his revolutionary verse in the New Masses, a stylish journal of the interwar American literary Left.
CULTURE
Lu_lu\U0001f498
Lu_lu💘
@luciame16
Some thoughts on episode 54 of #Hercai

If you ever cross the distance and come to me, come with love that blooms in your heart.
~ Şems-i Tebrizi

#Reyyan #Miran #ReyMir #EbruŞahin #AkınAkınözü
#HercaiThoughts


1
I have to make a note before writing about this episode. I was the person (still am) who thinks that bringing back D. was a bad idea. I repeat it that for me the writing of S1 and S2 is like tossed into the bin with that plot evolution, but they had to invent something+
#Hercai

2
+ to be able to continue to prolong the general story after Aslan’s story did not work out. All the suffering of M., all the crying seems for “nothing” for two seasons and we viewers are also kind of fed up in seeing him cry all the time when with the upcoming episodes+
#Hercai

3
+he is justified the most to cry. With her resurrection now the attention shifts back to Miran’s storyline and I don’t know if I like this to be honest. This said, Dilsha is here and we have to deal with her.
#Hercai

4
So, my comments are going to be how I find they wrote her into the story, the details we get to know, the flashbacks we get to see, the way it was filmed and directed, with leaving out if I agree on it or not but describing along the way what I saw.
#Hercai
CULTURE
Advertisement
Nick Kapur
Nick Kapur
@nick_kapur
A thread of images from a Japanese illustrated history of America from 1861.

Here is George Washington (with bow and arrow) pictured alongside the Goddess of America. 1/


Here is Christopher Columbus (seated at center) reporting his discovery of America to Queen Isabella of Spain.

So far, kinda normal, but wait for it.... 2/


Now it's the American Revolution. Here is George Washington defending his wife "Carol" from a British official named "Asura" (same characters as the Buddhist deity). 3/


And here is Washington's "second-in-command" John Adams battling an enormous snake. 4/


Here is Washington and his wife "Carol" meeting an extremely youthful Benjamin Franklin, who has an impressive squat. 5/
CULTURE
Dr. Leah Stokes
Dr. Leah Stokes
@leahstokes
For my book, I interviewed Texan Republicans, Democrats, oil guys + clean energy pioneers. Texas was once leading in wind energy, with GOP support. Now we get lies, from the Gov on down on renewables. What happened?

Lessons from Short Circuiting Policy https://t.co/KtxaBci5oC 🧵


Texas' challenges are not from "learning too many renewable energy lessons from California.” - Rep. Crenshaw

Texas passed its first renewable energy target in 1999, 3 years before California. The law was signed by, Gov. George W. Bush — you may recall he’s a Republican.

Gov. Bush was so proud of Texas’ leadership on wind energy, that he campaigned on it when running for President in 2000.

The "bill he signed in 1999 will make Texas the country’s largest market for renewable energy by 2009."
https://t.co/T4dKZ5qGnA


In 2005, Texas passed another big wind energy law, which included $7 billion for transmission.

It was sponsored by Republican state Senator Troy Fraser and signed by Republican Gov. Rick

With Gov. Abbott going on TV this week and lying, blaming the boogeyman “Green New Deal” and wind turbines for Texas’ current crisis, GOP leadership on renewables feels like ancient history.

What happened over the past 15
CULTURE
Chronicles of Nate\u2122\ufe0f
Chronicles of Nate™️...
@ChroniclesNate
20 of my favorite Jim Rohn quotes:

[Thread]


Don’t wish it was easier, wish you were better

Don’t wish for less problems, wish for more skills

Don’t wish for less challenges, wish for more wisdom

~Jim Rohn~

If you don’t design your own life plan, chances are you’ll fall into someone else’s plan

And guess what they have planned for you?

Not much

~Jim Rohn~

Formal education will make you a living; self-education will make you a fortune

~Jim Rohn~

How sad to see a father with money and no joy

The man studied economics, but never studied happiness

~Jim Rohn~
CULTURE

You May Also Like

Melissa (she/her)
Melissa (she/her)
@LiteraryMouse
In regards to the #CapitolCoup, I’m in a unique position. I monitored forums ahead of time and then was present for the coup itself.

These are my observations based on what I saw and the evidence that’s been collected so far. I reserve the right to adjust my analysis as needed.

Let’s talk about the organization of the coup first. Seeing some people insist that the coup must have been highly planned and coordinated.

Yes and no. This was a #StochasticCoup. We’ll see little evidence of direct communication between Trump and the insurrectionists.

Within the insurrectionists, there was not one group that executed the storming of the Capitol.

Rather, there were a number of smaller groups working independently towards the same goal. I expect you’ll see little evidence that these various groups communicated with each other.

What you will see is detailed planning and coordination within these small groups.

Then there were the joyriders, those Trump supporters who weren’t directly involved in any plotting but who were more than happy to go along for the ride once the coup was in motion.

After four years, the insurrectionists were carefully attuned to Trump’s messaging.

Every tweet and statement of his was treated as marching orders and carefully dissected for meaning.

It’s why shutting down Trump’s Twitter account was so important.
POLITICS , INSURRECTIONISTS
Chris Herd
Chris Herd
@chris_herd
I've spoken to 1,500+ people about remote work in the last 9 months

A few predictions of what is likely to emerge before 2030

[ a thread ] 💻🏠🌍

🚜 Rural Living: World-class people will move to smaller cities, have a lower cost of living & higher quality of life

These regions must innovate quickly to attract that wealth. Better schools, faster internet connections are a must

⏰Asynchronous Work: Offices are instantaneous gratification distraction factories where synchronous work makes it impossible to get stuff done

Tools that enable asynchronous work are the most important thing globally remote teams need. A lot of startups will try to tackle this

⚽️Hobbie Renaissance: Remote working will lead to a rise in people participating in hobbies and activities which link them to people in their local community

This will lead to deeper, more meaningful relationships which overcome societal issues of loneliness and issolation

🌍Diversity & Inclusion: The most diverse and inclusive teams in history will emerge rapidly

Companies who embrace it have a first-mover advantage to attract great talent globally. Companies who don't will lose their best people to their biggest competitors
REMOTE WORK
Advertisement
Anu Satheesh \U0001f1ee\U0001f1f3
Anu Satheesh 🇮🇳...
@AnuSatheesh5
#Guruvayur_Krishna_Bhakthi  🕉
#Guruvayur
#Storytime
Beautiful Story of Guruvayurappan

Poonathanam Namboothiri was a great devotee of Guruvayurappan. One day Poonthanam was going to Guruvayur Kshetram. It was night time and eventhough Namboothiri was tired he continued to walk


Suddenly some thieves came and blocked his way. Poonthanam cried for Shri Krishna to help. Thieves snatched all valuables from him, but Namboothiri holding his Bhaghavatam book called Shri Krishna to help. That time a man came in a horse back and fought with thieves and protected


Namboothiri. Poonthanam thanked Krishna for helping him from danger and said to the man that "Shri Krishna has send you here and I don't know how to thank you".  The man smiled and told that he is Mangattachan, minister of  samoodhiris. Poonthanam once again thanked him and


gave his ring to Mangattachan as a token of thanks and continued his journey. He reached Guruvayur early morning for Nirmalya Darshan. Temple poojari came near him and told that Guruvayurappan came in his dreams and asked to hand over the ring to poonthanam.


When he opened Kshetra Nada poonthanam was surprised to see his ring on Guruvayurappan, which he gifted to Mangattachan. He understood that it was Guruvayurappan who came as Mangattachan to protect him. This is how Bhagwan treat his devotees.

Hare Krishna
🙏🕉🙏
ALL
Hector Navarro
Hector Navarro
@Hectorisfunny
I'm going to attempt to chronologically list all of the Marvel characters Stan Lee had a hand in creating. Working with his genius collaborators, Stan and his team produced an insane amount of iconic characters in a roughy ten year period. (Thread)


With his younger brother, writer Larry Lieber, and Jack "the King" Kirby:

Groot

Tales to Astonish #13 (November, 1960)


With writer Lieber, and artist Kirby:

Fin Fang Foom

Strange Tales #89 (October, 1961)


With the King, Stan gives birth to the Marvel Universe:

The Fantastic Four

Fantastic Four #1 (November, 1961)


With Jack Kirby:

Mister Fantastic

Fantastic Four #1 (November, 1961)
CULTURE
Billy Bostickson \U0001f3f4\U0001f441&\U0001f441 \U0001f193
Billy Bostickson 🏴👁&👁 ...
@BillyBostickson
@EricTopol @NBA @StephenKissler @yhgrad B.1.1.7 reveals clearly that SARS-CoV-2 is reverting to its original pre-outbreak condition, i.e. adapted to transgenic hACE2 mice (either Baric's BALB/c ones or others used at WIV labs during chimeric bat coronavirus experiments aimed at developing a pan betacoronavirus vaccine)

@NBA @StephenKissler @yhgrad 1. From Day 1, SARS-COV-2 was very well adapted to humans .....and transgenic hACE2 Mice


@NBA @StephenKissler @yhgrad 2. High Probability of serial passaging in Transgenic Mice expressing hACE2 in genesis of SARS-COV-2


@NBA @StephenKissler @yhgrad B.1.1.7 has an unusually large number of genetic changes, ... found to date in mouse-adapted SARS-CoV2 and is also seen in ferret infections.
https://t.co/9Z4oJmkcKj


@NBA @StephenKissler @yhgrad We adapted a clinical isolate of SARS-CoV-2 by serial passaging in the ... Thus, this mouse-adapted strain and associated challenge model should be ... (B) SARS-CoV-2 genomic RNA loads in mouse lung homogenates at P0 to P6.
https://t.co/I90OOCJg7o
ALL